The fact that under the scheme of our Constitution, greater power is conferred upon the Centre vis-à-vis the states does not mean that states are mere appendages of the Centre. Comment
तथ्य यह है कि हमारे संविधान की योजना के तहत, राज्यों की तुलना में केंद्र को अधिक शक्ति प्रदान की गई है, इसका मतलब यह नहीं है कि राज्य केवल केंद्र के उपांग हैं। टिप्पणी 15 marks (250 words)
GS Paper-II : Federal Structure in the Indian Constitution
Answer Approach:
Key demand of the Question : Explain how states have their own sphere of powers in Indian constitution’s federal scheme
Introduction: giving a context of the question or defining federalism
Body Part:
In the first part, highlight the unitary bias.
In the next part, how states have their own sphere of powers
Last part, how these spheres have been facing challenges, mention examples
Conclusion: with a way forward
Model Answer:
Federalism is a system of government in which power is divided between a central authority and constituent political units.
The Indian Constitution, while providing for a federal structure, indeed confers greater powers upon the Centre compared to the states. This is evident in the distribution of powers, resources, and authority as delineated in the Constitution. However, it is crucial to recognize that this power asymmetry does not render the states as mere appendages of the Centre. Instead, the constitutional framework embodies a delicate balance, recognizing the distinct identities and roles of both levels of government.
Distribution of Legislative Powers:
- The Constitution demarcates legislative powers under the Union List, State List, and Concurrent List. While the Centre has exclusive authority over certain subjects, states possess considerable legislative autonomy.
Administrative Autonomy:
- The Constitution envisions a federal structure where states have their own administrative machinery.
Role of Rajya Sabha:
The Rajya Sabha, representing the states, acts as a check on the powers of the Lok Sabha. This bicameral structure ensures that state interests are safeguarded in the legislative process, contributing to a balanced federal arrangement.
Emergency Provisions:
The Constitution grants special powers to the Centre during emergencies, but these provisions are intended to be exceptional. Supreme Court interpreted Article 356 of the Constitution & ruled that the President’s decision would be subject to judicial review.
Eg. President’s rule in Uttarakhand (2016) and Arunachal Pradesh (2016), both of which were overturned by the Supreme Court.
The spirit of cooperative federalism with the help of institutions like NITI Aayog, GST Council should be strengthened. It is fundamental to the strength and resilience of India's federal democratic setup.







