Critically analyse the ED’s style of functioning in the context of Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002.
धन शोधन निवारण अधिनियम, 2002 के संदर्भ में ईडी की कार्यशैली का आलोचनात्मक विश्लेषण करें।
GS Paper III - Internal Security
GS Paper II - Statutory Bodies
Model Answer:
The Enforcement Directorate (ED) is an economic intelligence organisation.
- The ED is responsible for investigating the offences of money laundering under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 (PMLA).
- The ED has been playing a very significant role in controlling economic crimes.
- The ED conducts investigation to trace the assets derived from proceeds of crime, to provisionally attach the property and to ensure prosecution of the offenders
Why is the ED being Criticised
- The possibility of political misuse: ED has been criticised to impart fear among political opponents.
- The media has reported many cases of ED searches, seizures and arrests — which are outside the ED’s powers.
- Example: The Mines and MineralsAct, 1957 is not covered by the Schedule of the PMLA Act and offences in relation thereto are not “Scheduled Offences”. Yet, the ED is conducting inquiries with respect to the alleged illegal mining of sand.The conduct of the ED in this regard has resulted in severe criticism from the Supreme Court
- The ED’s focus is shifted from recovering the proceeds of crime to effecting pre-trial arrests and investigating the scheduled offence.
- The conviction rate of the ED under PMLA is very low
- The PMLA schedule has expanded to cover around 30 offences. It gives ED significant powers to investigate a range of crimes
- PMLA is pulled into the investigation of even “ordinary” crimes
- In several cases, the offences in the schedule of the Act have absolutely no relation to either narcotics or organised crime.
- Lack of Transparency and Clarity: The Enforcement Case Information Report (ECIR) not given to the accused.
Suggested Reforms:
- The ED should focus more on recovering crime proceeds
- Supreme Court of India in the Vijay Madanlal case declared, “Absent the existence of proceeds of crime, the authorities under the 2002 Act cannot step in or initiate any prosecution”.
- The actions of ED should be timely, fair and impartial to command credibility among the public.
Any loopholes in the operative part should be filled either through suitable action in the light of recent judgements of the Supreme Court







