A rational MSP is a better option than loan waivers, and it should be made a legal right so that farmers are assured of a decent income. Comment
तर्कसंगत एमएसपी ऋण माफी से बेहतर विकल्प है और इसे कानूनी अधिकार बनाया जाना चाहिए ताकि किसानों को अच्छी आय का आश्वासन दिया जा सके। टिप्पणी करें
Content to refer for answer writing:
Why do farmers from time to time demand minimum support prices (MSP) for their crops.
- Lacking the market power to influence the prices of their produce — or to even set the MRP (maximum retail price), as firms in most industries do — farmers sell at prevailing supply-and-demand-determined rates.
- Worse, while their crops are sold wholesale, they pay retail prices for everything from seeds, pesticides, diesel, and tractors to cement, medicines, toothpaste, and soap.
Price versus income support
- Cost-plus MSPs that are oblivious to demand conditions will distort farmers’ production decisions, resulting in the oversupply of some crops and an undersupply of others.
- Economists largely believe that it is better to give farmers “income”, instead of “price”, support. That would mean transferring a fixed sum of money annually into their bank accounts, whether on a per-farmer (as in the Centre’s PM-Kisan Samman Nidhi) or per-acre (the Telangana government’s Rythu Bandhu) basis.
- Direct income support schemes aren’t market-distorting and benefit all farmers, irrespective of which crop they grow in whatever quantity, and sell to whomsoever at any price.
- However, the flip side to everyone being paid the same money is: where does this leave the real producing farmer, who invests more resources, time, and effort in the field?
- Moreover, price support can be a useful tool for promoting crop diversification.
- Farmers are more likely to grow pulses, millets, and other nutrient-dense, less water-intensive crops than rice, wheat, or sugarcane if they are assured of MSP on the former.
How can MSP be guaranteed?
- The first is to force buyers to pay MSP. Sugar mills are required, by law, to pay cane growers a “fair and remunerative” or “state advised” price within 14 days of purchase. But this approach risks implementation hurdles (recurrent cane payment arrears are proof), or worse, the private trade choosing to not buy at all.
- The second is for government agencies to buy the entire marketable produce of farmers offered at MSP. That is unsustainable, both physically and fiscally.
- But there’s a third option: price deficiency payments (PDP).
- It entails the government not physically purchasing or stocking any crop, and simply paying farmers the difference between the market price and MSP, if the former is lower.
- Such payment would be on the quantity of crop they sell to the private trade.
- PDP was tried out first in Madhya Pradesh through a Bhavantar Bhugtan Yojana.
- Haryana’s PDP scheme, called Bhavantar Bharpai Yojana (BBY)
Way Forward:
- If a nationwide PDP scheme with 50% Central funding were to be implemented, it can perhaps incentivise other states to follow the examples of Madhya Pradesh and Haryana.
- They could, for a start, build the market infrastructure and systems that would ultimately enable even their farmers to get MSP, whether by law or otherwise.







