Do you think that cross-voting in Rajya Sabha elections is a serious threat to democracy. Discuss
क्या आपको लगता है कि राज्यसभा चुनाव में क्रॉस वोटिंग लोकतंत्र के लिए गंभीर खतरा है? चर्चा करें
Content for answer Writing:
Cross-voting in Rajya Sabha elections, where members of a legislative body vote for candidates outside their party's mandate or alliance, can be perceived as a challenge to the democratic process. While cross-voting in Rajya Sabha elections may pose challenges to democratic governance, it also reflects the complexities of political representation and the diversity of interests within a pluralistic society.
Potential Threats to Democracy:
Undermining Party Discipline:
- Cross-voting undermines the principle of party discipline, which is essential for the functioning of parliamentary democracy. Elected representatives are expected to adhere to the party's mandate and ideology, reflecting the will of the electorate who voted for the party's platform.
Manipulation of Electoral Outcomes:
- Cross-voting can lead to the manipulation of electoral outcomes, particularly in close contests or situations where political alliances are fragile. It may result in the election of candidates who do not necessarily represent the interests or ideologies of their constituents.
Erosion of Trust in Political Institutions:
- Instances of cross-voting can erode public trust in political institutions and elected representatives. When elected officials prioritize personal interests or external pressures over party loyalty and constituency concerns, it undermines the credibility and legitimacy of the democratic process.
In order to rein in the MLAs from such cross-voting, an amendment to the Representation of the People Act, 1951 was carried out in 2003. Section 59 of the Act was amended to provide that the voting in elections to Rajya Sabha shall be through an open ballot.
- However, the elections to Rajya Sabha are not treated as a proceeding within the Legislative Assembly. The Election Commission, drawing reference to Supreme Court judgments, had issued a clarification in July 2017.
- The Supreme Court in Kuldip Nayar versus Union of India (2006), upheld the system of open ballot for Rajya Sabha elections. It reasoned that if secrecy becomes a source for corruption, then transparency has the capacity to remove it.
- However, in the same case the court held that an elected MLA of a political party would not face disqualification under the Tenth Schedule for voting against their party candidate. He/she may at the most attract disciplinary action from their political party.
- Way Forward: Voting by an MLA against his/her political party in a Rajya Sabha election may well be construed as a strong reason to infer that the member had voluntarily given up membership of such party.
- If the court decides so, this would be a valid ground for disqualification under the Tenth Schedule. It would hopefully act as a deterrent against such cross-voting in the future
- Efforts to address the underlying causes of cross-voting, promote ethical leadership, strengthen party discipline, and enhance electoral integrity are essential for safeguarding the principles of democracy and upholding the trust of the electorate in their elected representatives.







